Pulse Control improves the micromachining of hard materials

By: Sami T. Hendow

Multiwave Photonics

Pulsed fiber lasers are being used extensively in microstructuring of materials.  Various reports indicate that the temporal shape and duration of the pulse are important for increasing the material removal rates and cutting speed.  In particular, the leading edge, which is often observed in pulsed fiber lasers, is suggested to enhance the process of cutting and material ablation.

In this report, a pulsed MOPA fiber laser is used to demonstrate that significant improvement in ablation quality and cutting speeds of hard materials, such as silicon, can be obtained if the pulse shape, pulse energy, and peak power are controlled and optimized.

An important capability of the MOPA laser used is the freedom to change one of the pulse parameters without affecting the others.  This enables us to optimize the process for the application.  For example, we can adjust the pulse peak power, while maintaining pulse energy to suite the application, or we can adjust repetition frequency without affecting the shape of the pulse, up to the maximum average power for the laser.

Optimization of the ablation process

The leading edge is observed to enhance material removal and to speed up wafer cutting speeds.  However, this is seen to be important only when the pulse has sufficient tail energy.  This later segment of the pulse contributes to heating of the surface of the material, which in turn is coupled with the leading edge to enhance material ablation.  Alternately, a short pulse with high peak power and no tail, leads only to ablation of a thin layer.  This is often attributed to the formation of highly ionized plasma which prevents the remainder of the pulse from reaching the material.

To facilitate the study, the MOPA laser is operated in two separate modes of operation; (1) constant pulse energy as the pulse width is adjusted; and (2) constant output peak power as pulse width and repetition frequency are changed.  In all cases, the system is operated with an average power of 10W at the work piece.

The MOPA system is configured to operate with pulses ranging from 10ns to 250ns, and with pulse repetition frequencies from single shot to 750kHz.  Pulse energy can be up to 0.5mJ, and peak power of up to 10kW.  On target, these translate to the high fluence levels of over 150J/cm2, or over 3GW/cm2 peak power levels.

Data is presented that demonstrates a factor of two improvements in cutting time and material removal if pulse peak power, energy and shape are controlled and optimized.  Other data is presented for scribing and percussion drilling of mono and multi-crystalline silicon, aluminium-coated silicon and copper.

Fig.1. To optimize the process of machining, the pulsed MOPA laser is operated in two configurations: (A) pulses of equal energy but different widths and peak power, and (B) pulses of different widths but with the same peak power.

The above brief overview was extracted from its original abstract and paper presented at The International Congress on Applications of Lasers & Electro-Optics (ICALEO) in Orlando, FL. To order a copy of the complete proceedings from this conference click here

Paper M209

Laser Beam Welding of Experimental Trip Steels

By:  Álvaro Prada

In the last few years, the use of Advanced High Strength Steels in the automotive sector has been increasing steadily for the manufacturing of structural and safety parts. Indeed these steels make possible an improvement of passengers´ safety maintaining a reasonable weight. Five years ago, it was predicted that TRIP steels would be one of the most popular family of AHSS. However nowadays its use is not so significant and generally high strength dual-phase steels or martensitic steels are preferred in spite of the very good forming property of TRIP steels. Probably one of the major reasons is the behaviour of TRIP welded parts, whatever the process. Figure 1 presents comparative forming results between laser welded TRIP and DP joints. In order to understand better the manufacturing process of TRIP steels as well as their behaviour when forming and welding, the Spanish government is funding a project integrated by 4 members, each one leading a specific part of the study: ITMA is designing and manufacturing the steels, CEIT is selecting the best thermo mechanical cycles, CTM is evaluating the forming properties as manufactured and also of the welded joints, and AIMEN is studying the behaviour of experimental steels when welding.

In this project, the main objectives are to design TRIP steels in order to enhance their weldability, to assess the behaviour of experimental TRIP steels versus commercial TRIP steels, to make a comparison between TRIP steels and DP steels behaviour and finally to study the weld behaviour using different processes such as LBW, PAW and RSW.

The consecution of the objectives of the project will make possible:

  • To increase the knowledge about the behaviour of these steels versus welding processes.
    • To develop know-how for the production of TRIP steels and future new steels in Spain.
    • To seek innovative solutions in order to solve the actual limitations of the most common commercial grades.

In the work presented, the main action performed is to study the effect of laser radiation on the microstructure and the mechanical response and weldability of experimental and commercial TRIP steels mainly for two types of joints: the autogenous lap weld employed in reinforcements and in subsets of security and commitment, and the butt weld employed in Tailored Welded Blanks.

The main conclusions obtained are:

  • It was possible to obtain, at laboratory scale, TRIP steels that present similar welding properties to commercial TRIP steels.
  • The butt laser welds present higher tensile strength than the base material, but lower formability.
  • When laser welding, the fusion zones present very high hardness values. No decrease of hardness respect to the base material was observed in the HAZ.
  • Using LBW process, the formability of dissimilar TRIP-XES joint is higher than the DP-XES joint.

The above brief overview was extracted from its original abstract and paper presented at The International Congress on Applications of Lasers & Electro-Optics (ICALEO) in Orlando, FL. To order a copy of the complete proceedings from this conference click here

Hybrid Laser-GMAW Welding

By: Brian Victor

With increasing material costs and competition, the need for high-productivity welding processes in manufacturing is greater than ever.  Hybrid welding, increasingly referred to as HLAW (hybrid laser-arc welding), is a high productivity welding process that combines laser welding and gas metal arc welding (GMAW) in the same weld pool.  This combination results in a synergy that incorporates the benefits of each individual process:

  • Higher travel speeds and deeper penetration than conventional GMAW
  • Lower heat input and less distortion than arc welding
  • Less filler metal usage for a given thickness and smaller melt volume than arc welding
  • Greater gap tolerance than autogenous laser welding
  • Alloying addition and joint filling that is not possible with autogenous laser welding

For thin-sheet applications, the laser process stabilizes the hybrid weld pool enabling travel speeds of 5 m/min (200 ipm) or greater without the humping defects that usually occur in high-speed GMAW-only welding [Figure 1].  For thick-section applications, the laser keyhole process provides deep penetration through a zero-gap butt joint [Figure 2].  In both cases, the GMAW system supplies joint filling and alloy addition.  Numerous alloy systems in various applications and industries can benefit from hybrid welding.

  • Steel
  • Stainless
  • Aluminum
  • Copper
  • Nickel / Inconel
  • Titanium
  • Zirconium
  • Aerospace
  • Automotive
  • Defense
  • Energy
  • Heavy Manufacturing
  • Oil and Gas

Recent hybrid work at EWI has encompassed mild and high strength steel, titanium, and aluminum.  With 10kW of laser power, the hybrid process can penetrate a 0.50-in. steel square-butt joint in a single pass at approximately 2 m/min (80 ipm).  Under EWI’s Cooperative Research Program (CRP) last year, hybrid welding of steel was investigated to determine the effects of multiple process variables including focal position, beam to wire distance, root shielding gas, and process orientation.  Also, a custom illumination system was developed for high speed video to evaluate the process during welding [Figure 3].  As part of this year’s CRP work, mechanical properties of thick-section HSLA 100 hybrid welds will be evaluated in addition to thick-section and high-speed hybrid welding of steel, aluminum and titanium.

The above brief overview was extracted from its original abstract and paper presented at The International Congress on Applications of Lasers & Electro-Optics (ICALEO) in Orlando, FL. To order a copy of the complete proceedings from this conference click here

On the Temperature Distributions and Thermal Stresses Induced in Laser Solid Freeform Fabrication of Multi-material Structures

By: Masoud Alimardani

The use of multi-material structures has shown a rapid increase in the past decade due to new fabrication technologies. In many different multidisciplinary engineering applications such as biomedical applications inconsistent material properties are required in order to enhance mechanical properties and functionality of an object. Conventional methods cannot properly create objects in which materials change gradually from one to another. Sharp interfaces between different materials cause stress concentrations that ultimately create delamination and cracks between layers of different materials. Another major problem in fabrication of multi-material structures is controlling the variation of different desired materials. Laser Solid Freeform Fabrication (LSFF) technique has great potential for the creation of multi-material structures in which material composition varies from one layer to another or from one point to another point in the same layer. Continue reading

Analysis of penetration depth fluctuations in single-mode fiber laser welds

By: Jung-Ho Cho, Dave F Farson, Matt J Reiter

The Ohio State University, Laboratory for Multiscale Processing & Characterization,

Single-mode fiber lasers produce high power beams with nearly perfect beam quality, meaning that they can be focused to a very small diameter spot with relatively long focal length optics. It is becoming increasingly clear that these laser beam optical qualities are not always ideal for welding. Welds made with these lasers are uniquely sensitive to a defect known as penetration spiking. Such abrupt fluctuations in weld penetration depth have long been a problem in electron beam welding but have not been observed in laser welding before the advent of high power single-mode lasers. In this work, the effect of laser power, travel speed and focus length and spiking severity was studied and techniques for reducing spiking were demonstrated. As an initial step, the frequency response of the weld penetration depth to sinusoidal power modulations was quantified. It was found that the laser weld keyhole responded as a second-order dynamic system for modulation frequencies in the range from 100Hz to 1000Hz. Thus, at upper end of this range, the sinusoidal response of the laser weld penetration to the sinusoidal power modulation was practically undetectable above the background noise of natural “random” spiking fluctations. However, the frequency response tests also showed that  power modulation in the frequency range from 900Hz to 3kHz had the good effects,  significantly decreasing the magnitude of the spiking penetration fluctuations. At some frequencies, the sinusoidal power modulation was able to completely eliminate spiking, but the effect was very sensitive to parameters and hence not very reliable for actual applications.  A second technique for spiking suppression in electron beam welds is “beam stirring”, where the focus spot is scanned in small circles at high frequency as it is scanned along the weld joint at the welding travel speed. This beam stirring technique was investigated for spiking suppression in the single-mode fiber laser welding process using a galvanometer scanner to produce simultaneous circular oscillation and linear travel of the focus spot. This spiking suppression technique was found to be much less sensitive to parameter settings and nearly eliminated spiking over broader ranges of circular oscillation frequency and diameter.

The above brief overview was extracted from its original abstract and paper presented at The International Congress on Applications of Lasers & Electro-Optics (ICALEO) in Orlando, FL. To order a copy of the complete proceedings from this conference click here